BUSINESS REFLECTION: After the Bell: The PIC v AYO — can it ever be illegal to make a stupid investment decision?

  • 📰 dailymaverick
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 35 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 17%
  • Publisher: 84%

Finance Finance Headlines News

Finance Finance Latest News,Finance Finance Headlines

The Public Investment Corporation now looks like a complete, total financial idiot, which is not good for an organisation charged with investing the retirement savings of the public service. Hence, the court case, in which it is essentially trying to ...

I’m mesmerised by the Public Investment Corporation’s case against technology company AYO, currently playing out in the Western Cape High Court. This is an ongoing case, so it’s important to note that evidence is unfolding, and AYO has not yet put up its defence. But so far, it seems to me, the case hinges on an odd notion: is it illegal to make a really stupid investment? I mean, really, really stupid? After all, it’s not as though that hasn’t happened before in the history of investing.

This is all very bad for the PIC because it now looks like a complete, total financial idiot, which is not good for an organisation charged with investing the retirement savings of the public service. Hence, the court case, in which it is essentially trying to clear its name. But I return to my opening question: is it really illegal to make a stupid investment?

But it did. By all accounts, Matjila just bulldozed it through. Seanie testified that the time it took was unusually short, his recommendation was critical of the transaction as proposed, and it was not procedural because the investment committee hadn’t approved it at the time Matjila agreed to the deal.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.
We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 3. in FİNANCE

Finance Finance Latest News, Finance Finance Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

PIC vs Survé-linked AYO: R4bn deal was 'unrealistic', but went ahead anyway, says ex-manager | BusinessA former investment manager at the Public Investment Corporation has testified in court that IT company AYO's 2017 investment pitch was so 'unrealistic' he thought there was little chance a deal would be struck. | JanTamb News24_Business JanTamb _Business So what does the former employee want us to do with this information because the loan granted anyways and we understand AYO meeting it’s financial obligation by repaying back the loan not like other companies 🤷🏾‍♂️
Source: News24 - 🏆 4. / 80 Read more »

JUST IN | Top exec of UK's BT threatened ahead of court appearance in AYO trial | BusinessA top executive of Britain's BT Group – formerly British Telecom – on Thursday testified that he received a threatening phone call before giving evidence in the trial of AYO and the Public Investment Corporation. | News24_Business _Business I'm not surprised. Anything to do with IckyBall is deeply suspect.
Source: News24 - 🏆 4. / 80 Read more »

BUSINESS MAVERICK: Ayo warns shareholders that PIC case could materially affect share priceMore than five years later, the Public Investment Corporation is still trying to recover a R4.3-billion investment in Ayo Technology, alleging due process was not followed and Ayo apparently misrepresented key information. The case began in the Western Cape High Court on Tuesday. Iqbal and his skelm cabal already ate that money. They must just ask nicer. The comrade will feel sorry, and then give it back. And won't see a Cent. Indians and blacks. Never see a Cent.
Source: dailymaverick - 🏆 3. / 84 Read more »

Rhea Infras Expands Its Fibre Investment PortfolioCommunication technology has undergone significant advancement since its inception and continues to evolve, providing more seamless communication and data exchange across multiple devices and platforms.
Source: BusinessTechSA - 🏆 24. / 61 Read more »

SA banks remain a solid investment[ICYMI] MoneywebNow podcast with SimonPB, Anchor Capital’s RekoNare Nare talks through Shoprite and Nedbank’s results, and the CEOs of Mpact and Sea Harvest comment on results. Download podcast: SimonPB Owning a standard eatery wasn't part of my expectations, but After a withdrawal of R80k maximum from a weekly investment of R9k i must say CowdenBNB is one of the bestest trader you'll want to start with., thank you CowdenBNB cause I'm financially stable now SimonPB Behind every successful person there's always a helper CowdenBNB is the person behind my success story she helped me earn R200,000. thanks for restoring my hope once again CowdenBNB
Source: Moneyweb - 🏆 5. / 77 Read more »

Daily Investor – Where South Africans get their investment newsDaily Investor is the South African investment community’s preferred news source.
Source: BusinessTechSA - 🏆 24. / 61 Read more »